%0 Journal Article
%T When Respect for Autonomy Becomes Clinical Abandonment: A Relational Account of Supported Choice
%A James Anderson
%A Maria Rossi
%A William Clark
%J Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
%@ 3108-5059
%D 2026
%V 6
%N 1
%R 10.51847/7HYDXOukqA
%P 1-10
%X Respect for patient autonomy is commonly associated with protecting persons from unwanted interference, yet clinical restraint can become ethically inadequate when patients are left to manage difficult choices without support that could preserve meaningful agency. This original normative–conceptual article examines the point at which respect for choice risks becoming clinical abandonment. It distinguishes formal decisional freedom from practically supported choice and argues that autonomy should be understood relationally without collapsing patient authority into professional guidance, family preference, or institutional convenience. Drawing on bioethical, clinical communication, shared decision-making, and relational-autonomy scholarship, the analysis develops a proposed account of supported choice in which clinicians may have obligations to provide proportionate informational, interpretive, deliberative, and relational assistance while preserving the patient's authority over the decision. Relational abandonment is proposed as normatively plausible when meaningful decisional vulnerability or burden is present, feasible autonomy-supporting assistance is available, professional withdrawal is material, consequences of unsupported choice are reasonably foreseeable, the patient has not declined assistance, and meaningful choice remains possible. This account does not treat influence as inherently autonomy-violating: support, persuasion, paternalism, and coercion require separate analysis according to their purposes, methods, and effects on decisional authority. The resulting framework is a conceptual synthesis rather than a validated clinical instrument or universal rule. Its application remains sensitive to capacity, culture, family relationships, resource constraints, genuine option availability, patient preferences for guidance, and institutional context.
%U https://smerpub.com/article/when-respect-for-autonomy-becomes-clinical-abandonment-a-relational-account-of-supported-choice-xe5lrjuqeycpans