We'd appreciate your feedback. Send feedback Subscribe to our newsletters and alerts


Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine

2026 Volume 6 Issue 1

From Informed Consent to Informed Dependence: Rethinking Autonomy in AI-Mediated Clinical Care


, ,
  1. Department of AI Ethics and Clinical Autonomy, Faculty of Medicine, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland.
  2. Department of Informed Dependence and Patient-Provider Relationships, Faculty of Medicine, University of Eastern Finland, Kuopio, Finland.
Abstract

Artificial intelligence is becoming embedded in diagnosis, documentation, communication, risk prediction, and clinical decision support. These uses complicate autonomy because patients may depend not only on a clinician's recommendation but also on models they cannot inspect, organizations that select and monitor those models, data infrastructures that may change, and clinicians whose own knowledge and communication are increasingly mediated by AI. Conventional informed consent remains indispensable, but its episodic emphasis on authorizing a recognizable intervention may incompletely address these continuing dependencies. This article develops informed dependence as a proposed bioethical concept for identifying when autonomy requires attention to the conditions under which patients must rely on AI-mediated clinical arrangements. It distinguishes epistemic, technical, organizational, and relational dependence and argues that materially consequential dependence may generate differentiated duties of disclosure, oversight, continuity, and feasible exit or recourse. The framework does not require patients to understand model mechanics or demand separate consent for every computational process. Instead, it directs attention toward information and safeguards that affect whether reliance is reasonably intelligible, contestable, monitored, and revisable. This account reframes consent as extending beyond a single authorization moment while preserving proportionality and clinical practicability. Its principal limitations are conceptual rather than empirical: the proposed categories and duties have not been validated as a clinical consent model, their relevance will vary across technologies and jurisdictions, and meaningful alternatives may sometimes be unavailable. Informed dependence is therefore offered as a normative lens for analyzing autonomy under sustained AI mediation, not as a universal legal rule or implementation-ready consent standard.


How to cite this article
Vancouver
Lahtinen M, Salo E, Virtanen J. From Informed Consent to Informed Dependence: Rethinking Autonomy in AI-Mediated Clinical Care. Asian J Ethics Health Med. 2026;6(1):114-23. https://doi.org/10.51847/9yLVG44HBY
APA
Lahtinen, M., Salo, E., & Virtanen, J. (2026). From Informed Consent to Informed Dependence: Rethinking Autonomy in AI-Mediated Clinical Care. Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine, 6(1), 114-123. https://doi.org/10.51847/9yLVG44HBY
Articles
Smart Home Health Technologies and Elder Care: Mapping Ethical Issues Through a Systematic Review
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 2 Issue 1, 2022 | Ana Seselja Perisin
Human Rights and Bioethical Principles in Correctional Settings: A Systematic Review of the Evidence
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 4 Issue 1, 2024 | Delyse Leadbeatter
Building Trust in the Application of Machine Learning Algorithms for Rare Disease Diagnosis
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 3 Issue 1, 2023 | Lukas Lembo
The Ethics of Reversibility: Why High-Stakes Clinical Decisions Need Paths Back
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Wouter De Smet
The Right to a Human Reason: Contestability in High-Stakes Clinical Decisions
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Rafael Mendoza
Moral Residue After Algorithmic Advice
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Wei Zhang
From Informed Consent to Informed Dependence: Rethinking Autonomy in AI-Mediated Clinical Care
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Mikko Lahtinen

About SMER

Find out more