We'd appreciate your feedback. Send feedback Subscribe to our newsletters and alerts


Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine

2026 Volume 6 Issue 1

Who Owns a Shared Decision? Distributed Responsibility in Interprofessional Clinical Judgment


, ,
  1. Department of Interprofessional Ethics and Shared Decision-Making, Faculty of Medicine, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany.
  2. Department of Clinical Judgment and Distributed Responsibility, Faculty of Medicine, LMU Munich, Munich, Germany.
Abstract

Shared decision-making is commonly described as a collaborative clinical ideal, yet collaboration does not by itself determine who owns the responsibilities generated by a decision. In interprofessional care, patients, physicians, nurses, consultants, family members, and institutions may contribute different forms of knowledge, influence, authority, implementation work, and retrospective answerability. This philosophical analysis examines that unresolved ownership problem by treating the clinical decision episode, rather than a single moment of consent, as the relevant unit of analysis. It distinguishes epistemic, communicative, procedural, and moral contributions from implementation responsibility and retrospective accountability, and argues that these dimensions can overlap without becoming interchangeable. The analysis further proposes that responsibility may be distributed across persons, professions, institutions, and phases of care without being diluted into collective nonresponsibility. On this basis, the article develops a proposed Decision-Ownership Framework for identifying who knew, communicated, authorized, influenced, acted, and remains answerable within a shared decision. The framework is intended as a conceptual and normative aid rather than a validated clinical tool, legal allocation rule, or quantitative method for apportioning blame. Its usefulness is therefore bounded by differences in capacity, professional authority, institutional structure, jurisdiction, clinical urgency, epistemic power, and the changing configuration of responsibility across time. The central claim is that a shared decision can be genuinely co-produced while still generating differentiated and sometimes overlapping obligations. Accordingly, ownership should be reconstructed as a pattern of responsibility relations rather than a single transferable status attached to one decision-maker.


How to cite this article
Vancouver
Müller H, Schmidt A, Weber T. Who Owns a Shared Decision? Distributed Responsibility in Interprofessional Clinical Judgment. Asian J Ethics Health Med. 2026;6(1):11-20. https://doi.org/10.51847/qe0JPE52ri
APA
Müller, H., Schmidt, A., & Weber, T. (2026). Who Owns a Shared Decision? Distributed Responsibility in Interprofessional Clinical Judgment. Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine, 6(1), 11-20. https://doi.org/10.51847/qe0JPE52ri
Articles
Smart Home Health Technologies and Elder Care: Mapping Ethical Issues Through a Systematic Review
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 2 Issue 1, 2022 | Ana Seselja Perisin
Human Rights and Bioethical Principles in Correctional Settings: A Systematic Review of the Evidence
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 4 Issue 1, 2024 | Delyse Leadbeatter
Building Trust in the Application of Machine Learning Algorithms for Rare Disease Diagnosis
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 3 Issue 1, 2023 | Lukas Lembo
The Ethics of Reversibility: Why High-Stakes Clinical Decisions Need Paths Back
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Wouter De Smet
The Right to a Human Reason: Contestability in High-Stakes Clinical Decisions
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Rafael Mendoza
Moral Residue After Algorithmic Advice
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Wei Zhang
From Informed Consent to Informed Dependence: Rethinking Autonomy in AI-Mediated Clinical Care
Asian Journal of Ethics in Health and Medicine
Vol 6 Issue 1, 2026 | Mikko Lahtinen

About SMER

Find out more